Montreal, September 15, 2008 • No 259

OPINION

 

Moin Yahya is an assistant professor of law at the University of Alberta and a fellow with the Institute for United States Policy Studies.

 
 

WHY CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS
ARE BOTH WRONG *

 

by Moin Yahya

 

          Conservatives always proclaim their desire for liberty, especially when it comes to the marketplace. Liberals proclaim their desire for liberty, especially when it comes to social institutions.

 

          What business does the government have in our economic affairs?, scream the conservatives every time the state decides to pass a new economic regulation, increase a tax, or subsidize a business. What business does the government have in our bedrooms?, scream the liberals every time the state decides to regulate some social behaviour.

          Oddly enough, however, conservatives are the first to call for the state to criminalize all sorts of behaviour from gambling to pornography. Liberals, on the other hand, are the first to ask the state to impose all sorts of economic regulations to help the poor, the middle class, or whoever is suffering at the hands of the market.

          Recently, however, my oversimplified world of two camps, each specializing in tinkering with one half of our lives, has also broken down. We now have seen two so-called conservative governments north and south of our border grow the size and scope of the government by leaps and bounds.

          Such governments have seen fit to interject their meddling hands into such mundane matters as incandescent light bulbs and online gambling—they've banned both. Liberals in this country claim they want civil liberties, but under the guise of human rights commissions, have been responsible for massive large-scale attacks on freedom of speech. Liberal-minded child welfare agencies are now seizing children whose parents have the temerity to think differently than the rest of us.

          How is this all possible? The answer is simple: once Leviathan is created for one end, it is very easy for the beast to continue its quest to dominate all ends of our lives. The mistake both sides of the political spectrum make is assuming that somehow the machinery of oppression will only control those aspects of our lives that they expressly voted for.
 

"Once Leviathan is created for one end, it is very easy for the beast to continue its quest to dominate all ends of our lives. The mistake both sides of the political spectrum make is assuming that somehow the machinery of oppression will only control those aspects of our lives that they expressly voted for."


          Liberals who created the massive bureaucracy to regulate our healthcare and welfare now find the state spying on us in the name of the war on terror—and are understandably appalled at the curtailment of our civil liberties.

          Conservatives have created the massive police state in the name of the war on drugs and now the war on terror, and then are shocked when our economic liberties are curtailed. For that matter, conservatives are appalled when human rights commissions attempt to silence conservative voices. What amazes me is that both sides never seem to understand what the real source of the problem is.

          Ultimately, only libertarians have the answer to both these issues. True libertarians believe that the state has no role in our minds, bedrooms, or wallets. Libertarians understand that the state can never serve any legitimate purpose and that the best policy regarding the state is one that keeps it to a minimal status regardless of what social or economic ill is being addressed. At the end of the day, the free exchange of ideas, goods, and services will always dominate over any government solution.

          As tempting as the use of the state may be to politicians, libertarians must resist the easy and short-term expedient answers of more regulation. In a way, libertarians are Cassandras—always warning of the perils of the state but never being listened to!

          But as pessimistic as this may sound, there is always hope. Over 200 years ago, the founding fathers of the United States and over 100 years ago, the Canadian founding fathers, envisioned a system of government that respected our individual liberties. The liberties that we hold so dear.

          As Leviathan grows and chokes the life out of us, there will be no choice but to revert back to an era founded upon liberty. Millions of people in Germany realized these dreams when the Berlin Wall fell, and millions continue to do so around the world today. One day, we too will re-realize those dreams.

 

* This article was first published in the Western Standard and is reprinted with permission.

 

INDEX NO 259WHAT IS LIBERTARIANISM?ARCHIVESSEARCH QLLIST OF CONTRIBUTORS

SUBSCRIBE TO QLWHO ARE WE? LE BLOGUE DU QLREPRINT POLICY QUESTIONS? COMMENTS?

 

CURRENT ISSUE